The Definitive Primacy of Patient Autonomy over the Right to Life? Commentary on the Judgment of the European Court of Human Rights of 4 September 2022 on the Case of Mortier v. Belgium (appl. no. 78017/17)
Аннотация
This Commentary is an in-depth critical study of the European Court of Human Rights ruling in Mortier v. Belgium. The authors present the facts and the tribunal’s decision against the background of the ECtHR’s previous case law on terminally ill patients. Unlike Polish law, euthanasia and assisted suicide are permissible under Belgian law; thus, for the first time in its existence, the tribunal addressed not so much the permissibility of euthanasia as it examined the circumstances of its use. In this regard, it was critical for the authors to look at the ECtHR reasoning on the interplay between Articles 2 and 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights in order to answer the question of whether there has been an evolution or a revolution in the interpretation of the two laws. In the case of the rights of terminally ill patients, the issue is the right to make end-of-life decisions in accordance with the patient’s wishes, and whether the paradigm of patient autonomy has become the highest value in the doctor–patient relationship; this hich could also be indicated by recent changes to the International Code of Medical Ethics and the international text of the Hippocratic Oath (the Declaration of Geneva). In this context, it also becomes valuable to analyse the changes made to the Polish Code of Medical Ethics, which came into effect on 1 January 2025.Библиографические ссылки
Bosek, L. (Ed.). (2020). Ustawa o prawach pacjenta i Rzeczniku Praw Pacjenta. Komentarz. C.H. Beck.
Council of Europe. (1950). The Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms. The Convention in 1950 – The European Convention on Human Rights
Council of Europe. (1997). Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Dignity of the Human Being with Regard to the Application of Biology and Medicine (European Bioethics Convention). Council of Europe – Convention for the protection of Human Rights and Dignity of the Human Being with regard to the Application of Biology and Medicine: Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine (ETS No. 164) – Translations – Treaty Office
Council of Europe. (2006). Human rights handbooks, no. 8. http://www.echr.coe.int/LibraryDocs/HR%20handbooks/handbook08_en.pdf
European Court of Human Rights. (2022). Guide on Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights. https://www.echr.coe.int/documents/guide_art_8_eng.pdf
Garlicki, L. Hofmański P., Wróbel A. (Eds.), Konwencja o ochronie praw człowieka i podstawowych wolności. Tom, I. Komentarz do artykułów (pp. 1–18). C.H. Beck.
La monarchie belge (2002, 22 June). La loi belge sur l’eutanasie du 28.05.2002 (Moniteur Belge du 22.06.2002, 28515–28520). English version: The Belgian Act on Euthanasia of May 28th 2002, European Journal of Health Law (2003), 10, 329–335. https://apmonline.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/belgium-act-on-euthanasia.pdf
Harris, D.J., O’Boyle M., Bates, E.P., & Buckley, C.M. (2009). Law of the European Convention on Human Rights (2nd ed.). Oxford University Press.
Judgment of the ECtHR of 26 March 1985 on the case of X and Y v. Netherlands, 8978/80.
Judgment of the ECtHR of 16 December 1992 on the case of Niemietz v. Germany, 13710/88.
Judgment of the ECtHR of 27 February 1993 on the case of Z v. Finland, 22009/93.
Judgment of the ECtHR of 25 March 1993 on the case of Costello-Roberts v. UK, 13134/87.
Judgment of the ECtHR of 27 September 1995 on the case of McCann and Others v. UK, 18984/91.
Judgment of the ECtHR of 27 August 1997 on the case of M. S. v. Sweden, 20837/92.
Judgment of the ECtHR of 29 April 2002 on the case of Pretty v. UK, 2346/02.
Judgment of the ECtHR of 28 January 2003 on the case of Peck v. UK, 44647/98.
Judgment of the ECtHR of 20 January 2011 on the case of Haas v. Switzerland, 31322/07.
Judgment of the ECtHR of 19 July 2012 on the case of Koch v. Germany, 497/09.
Judgment of the ECtHR of 5 Juin 2015 on the case of Lambert et al. v. France, 46043/14.
Judgment of the ECtHR of 4 September 2022 on the case of Mortier v. Belgium, 78017/17.
Korff, D. (2006). A guide to the implementation of Article 2 of the European Convention on Human Rights (October 23, 2008). Council of Europe – Human Rights Handbook No. 8.
Martin, S. (2023). Assisted suicide and the European Convention on Human Rights. Routledge.
Michałkiewicz-Kądziela, E., & Šimić, G. (2023). The right to dignified death: A comparative legal discussion of euthanasia and assisted termination of life. Bialystok Legal Studies, 28(3), 181–195.
Naczelna Izba Lekarska, (Supreme Medical Council of Poland) (2024), Kodeks Etyki Lekarskiej, NIL – Kodeks Etyki Lekarskiej
Parsa-Parsi, R.W., Gillon, R., & Wiesing, U. (2024). The revised International Code of Medical Ethics unites doctors under one global medical ethos. British Medical Journal, 384, q449. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q449
Puppinck, G. (2014). The right to assisted suicide in the case law of the European Court of Human Rights. The International Journal of Human Rights, 7–8(18), 735–755.
Rainey, B., McCormick, P., & Ovey, C. (2014). Jacobs, White & Ovey: The European Convention on Human Rights (6th ed.). Oxford University Press.
République Française. (2005, 22 April). La loi n° 2005–2370 du 22 avril 2005 relative aux droits des malades et à la fin de vie. http://www.legifrance.gouv.fr
Samanta, J. (2015). Children and euthanasia: Belgium’s controversial new law. Diversity and Equality in Health and Care, 12(1), 4–5. https://www.primescholars.com/articles/children-and-euthanasia-belgiums-controversial-new-law.pdf
Schabas, W.A. (2015). The European Convention on Human Rights: A commentary. Oxford University Press.
Sejm of the Republic of Poland. (2008, 6 November). Ustawa o prawach pacjenta i Rzeczniku Praw Pacjenta z 6.11.2008 r., tekst jedn. Dz.U. z 20024, poz. 581 (PrPacjRPPU).
Świderska, M. (2023). Aspekty prawne terapii daremnej w okresie końca życia. Bialystok Legal Studies, 28(3), 71–107.
Tomczyk, M., Beloucif, S., Hervé, C., & Sopata, M.J. (2014). Sedacja u dorosłych u schyłku życia – doświadczenie francuskie. Medycyna Paliatywna, 6(1), 14–18. https://www.termedia.pl/Sedacja-u-doroslych-u-schylku-zycia-doswiadczenie-francuskie,59,22590,1,0.html
Weeramantry, J. (1996). Dissenting opinion of Judge Weeramantry on the case of the legality of the threat or use of nuclear weapons. I. C. J. Reports, 226.
Wnukiewicz-Kozłowska, A. (2016). Prawo do godnej śmierci (wspomagane samobójstwo, eutanazja, zaprzestanie uporczywej terapii) w interpretacji Europejskiego Trybunału Praw Człowieka). Prawo i Medycyna, 64(3), 46–70.
World Medical Association. (2023, 14 April). WMA International Code of Medical Ethics. https://www.wma.net/policies-post/wma-international-code-of-medical-ethics
World Medical Association. (2024, 31 May). WMA Declaration of Geneva. https://www.wma.net/policies-post/wma-declaration-of-geneva
Zannoni, D. (2020). Right or duty to live? Euthanasia and assisted suicide from the perspective of the European Convention on Human Rights. European Journal of Legal Studies, 12(2), 181–212.
