Competition and Self-Employed Workers in Europe: Some Critical Reflections
Keywords:
self-employment, collective bargaining, EU competition lawAbstract
This article examines the complex relationship between European competition law and the collective rights of self-employed workers. It focuses on the implications of the FNV Kunsten case (C-413/13), which established the limits of applying Article 101 TFEU to collective agreements involving self-employed workers, distinguishing between genuine and bogus self-employment. The author critically analyses the European Commission’s 2022 Guidelines on collective bargaining for self-employed persons, assessing their effectiveness in extending protection to economically dependent or vulnerable self-employed individuals. The paper argues that, despite progress, significant gaps remain for certain categories of self-employed workers, who still risk exclusion from collective bargaining rights under EU competition law.
References
Barnard, C. (2003). Social dumping and the race to the bottom: Some lessons for the European Union from Delaware? European Law Journal, 1, 563–584.
Broulík, J. (2024). Harm to workers in EU competition law: A sufficient condition for intervention [Working paper no. 12]. Amsterdam Center for Law & Economics.
Cengiz, F. (2021). The conflict between market competition and worker solidarity. Legal Studies, 1, 73–90.
Colin, C., & Lapeyre, W. F. (2017). Dependent self-employment: Trends, challenges and policy responses in the EU [Employment working paper no. 228]. International Labour Office.
Cordella C. (2021). Il lavoro dei rider: fenomenologia, inquadramento giuridico e diritti sindacali. Biblioteca ‘20 Maggio’, 2. https://csdle.lex.unict.it/sites/default/files/Documenti/Articoli/2021–2_Cordella.pdf
Countouris, N. (2007). The changing law of the employment relationship: Comparative analyses in the European context. Ashgate.
Countouris, N. (2018). The concept of ‘worker’ in European labour law: Fragmentation, autonomy and scope. Industrial Law Journal, 2, 192–225.
Daskalova, V. (2017). Regulating the new self-employed in the Uber economy: What role for EU competition law? Tilburg Law & Economics Center (TILEC) Law & Economics Research Paper Series. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3009120 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3009120.
Daskalova, V. (2018). Regulating the new self-employed in the Uber economy: What role for EU competition law? German Law Journal, 3, 461–508.
Davidov, G. (2017). ‘Subordination v. domination: Exploring the differences’. International Journal of Comparative Labour Law and Industrial Relations, 3, 365–389.
Delfino, M. (2017). Statutory minimum wage and subordination: FNV Kunsten Informatie judgment and beyond (CJEU, C-413/13). In M. Łaga, S. Bellomo, N. Gundt, & M. Boto (Eds.), Labour law and social rights in Europe. The jurisprudence of the international courts: Selected judgments (pp. 41–48). Gdansk University Press.
European Commission. (2022). Communication from the Commission: Guidelines on the application of Union competition law to collective agreements regarding the working conditions of solo self-employed persons, C-374/02.
European Parliament. (2024, 16 January). Resolution of 16 January 2024 on Competition Policy – Annual Report 2023 (2023/2077(INI) OJ C, C/2024/5705, 17.10.2024.
Giampà, G. (2024). Collective bargaining for solo self-employed persons in the European Union: Assessing the efficacy of the European Commission’s guidelines. Diritti lavori mercati international, 1, 243–265.
Giovannone, M. (2023). Guidelines on collective agreements regarding the solo self-employed persons: Another (controversial) immunity to EU competition rules. Diritti lavori mercati international, 2, 61–77.
Gramano, E. (2025). Collective rights, competition, and self-employed workers in the EU. International Journal of Comparative Labour Law and Industrial Relations, 2, 135–156.
Grosheide, E., & ter Haar, B. (2017). Employee-like worker: Competitive entrepreneur or submissive employee? Reflections on ECJ, C-413/13 (FNV Kunsten Informatie). In M. Łaga, S. Bellomo, N. Gundt, & M. Boto (Eds.), Labour law and social rights in Europe. The jurisprudence of the international courts: Selected judgments (pp. 21–41). Gdansk University Press.
ILO. (2016). Non-standard employment around the world: Understanding challenges, shaping prospects. International Labour Office.
Jurkowska-Gomułka, A., Piszcz, A., & Oliveira Pais, S. (2024). Collective agreements on working conditions of solo self-employed persons: Perspective of EU competition law. Białostockie Studia Prawnicze, 2, 65–82.
Judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union of 21 September 1999 on the case of Albany International BV v. Stichting Bedrijfspensioenfonds Textielindustrie, C-67/96.
Judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union (First Chamber) of 4 December 2014 on the case of FNV Kunsten Informatie en Media v. Staat der Nederlanden, C-413/13.
Kajander, A., & Kerikmäe, T. (2022). Gig economy workers in the European Union: Towards change in their legal classification. Revista CIDOB d’Afers Internacionals, 131, 117–136.
Lamannis, M. (2023). Collective bargaining in the platform economy: A mapping exercise of existing initiatives. Etui.
Leckey, C. (2020). ECJ clarifies ‘worker’ status under EU law in gig economy ruling (UK). European Employment Law Cases, 3, 210–213.
Monda, P. (2022). The notion of the worker in EU Labour Law: ‘Expansive tendencies’ and harmonisation techniques. Diritti lavori mercati international, 2, 93–123.
Perulli, A. (1996). Il lavoro autonomo. Contratto d’opera e professioni intellettuali. In A. Cicu, F. Messineo (Eds.), Trattato di Diritto Civile e Commerciale (pp. XII – 786). Giuffrè.
Prassl, J. (2018). Humans as a service: The promise and perils of work in the gig economy. Oxford University Press.
Rainone, S., & Countouris, N. (2021). Collective bargaining and self-employed workers: The need for a paradigm shift [Policy brief no. 11]. European Trade Union Institute.
Risak, M., & Dullinger, T. (2018). The concept of ‘worker’ in EU law. Etui.
Šmejkal, V. (2015). Competition law and the social market economy goal of the EU. International Comparative Jurisprudence, 1, 33–43.
Supiot, A. (2001). Beyond employment: Changes in work and the future of labour law in Europe. Oxford University Press.
Treu, T. (2016). Tipologie contrattuali nell’area del lavoro autonomo. Libro dell’anno del Diritto Treccani.
Zoppoli, A. (2024). Collaborazioni coordinate, dipendenza economica e contrattazione collettiva tra ordinamento italiano e diritto eurounitario. Lavoro diritti europa, 3, 1–13.
