Competition and Wage Regulation in the EU
Keywords:
minimum wage, competition, European Union, labour lawAbstract
The following article analyses the complex relationship between competition and wage regulation within the European framework, examining how the CJEU, the European Council and the European Parliament have intervened in the field of pay. Taking into consideration the lack of EU competence on wage matters, as established by Article 153, para. 5, TFEU, it is possible to identify significant changes, especially with the 2022 Directive on Adequate Minimum Wages. The article examines both how the European Commission has addressed issues related to pay during economic crises and CJEU judgments such as RegioPost and Bundesdruckerei, illustrating how wages are seen as a competitive element in public procurement or, as in the Werhof and Alemo-Herron cases, how competition rules often prevail over wage protection. For these reasons, the Directive on minimum wages aims to solve the problematic balance between competition and social security. To achieve this goal, it is necessary to ensure the concrete, practical implementation of the Directive or a reform of the Treaty or the Charter of Fundamental Rights to recognise the right to a fair wage.
References
Ales, E. (2008). Transnational wage-setting as a key feature of a socially oriented European integration: Role of and (questionable) limits on collective action [Working paper 63]. Centro studi di Diritto del Lavoro Europeo ‘Massimo D’Antona’.
Bavaro, V. (2012). Azienda, contratto e sindacato. Cacucci.
Blanpain, R. (2009). Memoirs of Roger Blanpain: ‘What can I do for you?’. Brugge.
Bogg, A (2014). Article 31 – Fair and just conditions. In S. Peers, T. Hervey, J. Kenner, & A. Ward (Eds.), The EU Charter of Fundamental Rights: A commentary (p. 833–868). Hart Publishing.
Brameshuber, E. (2026). EuGH bestätigt Kompetenzkonformität der ‘Mindestlohn-RL’ weitgehend – oder sollte sie doch ‘RL über unionsrechtliche Rahmenbedingungen für nationale Tarifverhandlungen’ heißen? Zeitschrift für Arbeits – und Sozialrecht, 1p. 1–10
Brino, V. (2016). Salario minimo legale e appalti pubblici: il caso RegioPost. Rivista giuridica del lavoro, 2, 135–147.
Deakin, S. (2013). Labour standards, social rights and the market: ‘Inderogability’ reconsidered. Giornale di diritto del lavoro e di relazioni industriali, II, p. 549–564.
Dorssemont, F. (2014). Collective action against the austerity measures. In N. Bruun, K. Loercher, & I. Schoemann (Eds.), The economic and financial crisis and labour law in Europe (pp. 153–170). Hart Publishing.
European Commission. (2009). Accompanying Document to the Proposal for a Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council Amending Capital Requirements Directive on Trading Book, Securitisation Issues and Remuneration Policies (COM(2009) 362 final, SEC(2009) 975 final, p. 3).
European Commission and Romania. (2009, 23 June). Memorandum concluded in Bucharest and Brussels, p. 1–20. https://commission.europa.eu/system/files/2016–09/ecfin_publication15409_en.pdf .
European Council. (1976, 9 February). Directive 76/207/EEC (O. J. L 39, 14.02.1976, pp. 40–42).
European Council. (1992, 27 July). Recommendation on Participation of Employees in Profits and Enterprise Results (92/443/EEC).
European Council. (1998, 20 July). Directive 98/59/EC (O. J. L 225, 12.08.1998, pp. 16–21).
European Council. (2001, 12 March). Directive 2001/23/EC (O. J. L 82, 22.03.2001, pp. 16–20).
European Council. (2002, 18 February). Regulation on Providing Medium-Term Financial Assistance for Member States’ Balances of Payments ((EC) no. 332/2002).
European Council. (2003, 4 November). Directive 2003/88/EC Concerning Certain Aspects of the Organisation of Working Time (O. J. L 299, 18.11.2003, pp. 9–19).
European Council. (2004, 31 March). Directive 2004/18/EC on the Coordination of Procedures for the Award of Public Works Contracts, Public Supply Contracts and Public Service Contracts (O. J. L 134, 30.04.2004, pp. 114–240).
European Council. (2010, 24 November). Directive 2010/76/EU Regarding Capital Requirements for the Trading Book and for Re-Securitisations, and the Supervisory Review of Remuneration Policies (O. J. L 329, 14.12.2010, pp. 3–35).
European Council. (2013, 26 June). Directive 2013/36/EU on Access to the Activity of Credit Institutions and the Prudential Supervision of Credit Institutions and Investment Firms (O. J. L 176, 27.06.2013, pp. 338–436).
European Council and European Parliament. (2022, 19 October) Directive 2022/2041 on adequate minimum wages in the European Union)
European Parliament. (2003). Resolution on Employee Financial Participation (P5-TA (2003) 0253).
European Parliament Committees. (2016). 05–12-2016 17:15: Hearing on Greek labour market reform. http://www.europarl.europa.eu/committees/en/events-hearings.html?id=20161202CHE00561
Guadagno, S. (2015). (Sub)appalto transnazionale e ambito di applicazione delle norme sul salario minimo. Rivista giuridica del lavoro e della previdenza sociale, 2, 33–45.
Guarriello, F. (2017). Legge e contrattazione collettiva in Europa: verso nuovi equilibri? Giornale di diritto del lavoro e di relazioni industriali, I,, pp. 107–127..
Hunt, J. (2003). Fair and just working conditions. In T. Hervey, & J. Kenner (Eds.), Economic and social rights under the EUCFR: A legal perspective (pp. 44–64. Hart Publishing.
Judgment of the CJEU of 13 July 1995 on the case of Jennifer Meyers v. Adjudication Office, C-116/94.
Judgment of the CJEU of 24 January 2002 on the case of Portugaia Construções Ldª, C-164/99.
Judgment of the CJEU of 9 March 2006 on the case of Hans Werhof v. Freeway Traffic Systems GmbH c Co. KG, C-499/04.
Judgment of the CJEU of 3 April 2008 on the case of Dirk Rüffert v. Land Niedersachsen, C-346/06.
Judgment of the CJEU of 15 April 2008 on the case of Impact v. Minister for Agriculture and Food and Others, C-268/06.
Judgment of the CJEU of 18 July 2013 on the case of Mark Alemo-Herron et alii v. Parkwood Leisure Ltd, C-426/11.
Judgment of the CJEU of 18 September 2014 on the case of Bundesdruckerei GmbH v. Stadt Dortmund, C-549/13.
Judgment of the CJEU of 26 March 2015 on the case of Gérard Fenoll v. Centre d’aide par le travail ‘La Jouvene’ and Association de parents et d’amis de personnes handicapées mentales (APEI), C-316/13.
Judgment of the CJEU of 9 July 2015 on the case of Ender Balkaya v. Kiesel Abbruch und Recycling Technik GmbH, C-229/14.
Judgment of the CJEU, of 11 November 2015, on the case of RegioPost GmbH & Co. KG v. Stadt Landau in der Pfalz, C-115/14.
Judgment of the CJEU of 27 April 2017 on the case of Asklepios Kliniken Langen-Seligenstadt GmbH v. Ivan Felja and Asklepios Dienstleistungsgesellschaft mbH v. Vittoria Graf, C-680/15 and C-681/15.
Judgment of the CJEU of 13 June 2017 on the case of Eugenia Florescu, Ioan Poiană, Cosmina Diaconu, Anca Vidrighin, Eugenia Elena Bădilă v. Casa Judeţeană de Pensii Sibiu, Casa Naţională de Pensii şi alte Drepturi de Asigurări Sociale, Ministerul Muncii, Familiei şi Protecţiei Sociale, Statul roman, Ministerul Finanţelor Publice, C-258/14.
Judgment of the CJEU of 11 November 2025 on the case of Kingdom of Denmark v. European Parliament, C-19/23.
Kenner, J. (2017). The enterprise, labour and the Court of Justice. In A. Perruli, & T. Treu (Eds.), Enterprise and social rights (pp. 199–247). Wolters Kluwer.
Leonardi, S. (2014). Salario minimo e ruolo del sindacato: il quadro europeo fra legge e contrattazione. Lavoro e diritto, I, 185–200..
Lo Faro, A. (2008). Is a decent wage part of a decent job? Answers from an enlarged Europe [Working paper 64]. Centro studi di Diritto del Lavoro Europeo ‘Massimo D’Antona’.
Lo Faro, A. (2026). I salari minimi, la Corte e la Direttiva salvata: tra continuità giurisprudenziale e sensibilità politica. Lavoro e diritto, I, pp. 57–77.
Menegatti, E. (2025). All’s well that ends well? The Court’s ‘saving’ of the Adequate Minimum Wage Directive. Italian Labour Law e-Journal, 2, 6–17.
Müller, T. (2025). I’m still standing: Transposition and political impact of the Directive on Adequate Minimum Wages in the EU. Italian Labour Law e-Journal, 2. p. 21–36.
Nogler, L. (2013). Sub article 36, co. 1, Cost. In R. De Luca Tamajo & O. Mazzotta (Eds.), Commentario breve alle leggi sul lavoro (pp. 36–48). Cedam.
Pallini, M. (2016). Dalla eterodirezione alla eteroorganizzazione: una nuova nozione di subordinazione? Rivista giuridica del lavoro e della previdenza sociale, 1, pp. 77–90
Ratti, L. (2025, 24–28 November). Out of the shadows: The Court of Justice and the limits of EU law competence on determining minimum wages. EU Live: The Week, 93.
Ricci, G. (2012). Il diritto alla retribuzione adeguata. Tutele costituzionali e crisi economica. Giappichelli.
Ricci, G. (2015). La retribuzione in tempi di crisi: diritto sociale fondamentale o variabile dipendente? In B. Caruso & G. Fontana (Eds.), Lavoro e diritti sociali nella crisi europea. Un confronto fra costituzionalisti e giuslavoristi (pp. 205–XXX). Il Mulino.
Santagata, R. (2011). Partecipazione azionaria dei lavoratori. In Enciclopedia del Diritto (pp. 1015–1017). Annali, Giuffrè.
Schulten, V. T., & Müller, T. (2013). A new European interventionism? The impact of the new European economic governance on wages and collective bargaining. European Public Service Union. www.epsu.org/IMG/pdf/EU_intervention_on_CB_Schulten_Mueller_final_version.pdf
